Our first regularly scheduled audit after The Salami Wars was just a few weeks after we returned from our research trip to France and Italy. (NB Audits are undertaken by private third-party auditors, who submit their reports to PrimeSafe, which is a statutory authority.)
I was determined to give The Auditor nothing to worry about â€“ I would show that we had understood our mistake in letting salamis leave the property, and that I keep an exemplary boning room.
The Auditor seemed quite solicitous as she commenced the audit â€“ she of course knew of The Salami Wars and appeared to have some sympathy for how we felt at the destruction of our food. The Audit was going very smoothly, paperwork all in order, the place spotlessâ€¦ and then she looked to the bottom of the display fridge.
â€˜Why are those smoked hocks in cryovac?â€™ she asked.
â€˜Um, because they keep better?â€™ I answered nervously.
â€˜But theyâ€™re ready-to-eat products, and you donâ€™t have a Listeria Management Plan,â€™ she declared.
Ah, crap. Bugger and gah! So they farking are.
Or are they? Letâ€™s examine the evidenceâ€¦
Ready-to-eat products are â€˜ordinarily consumed in the same state as that in which they are soldâ€™ according to the Australian Standard for the Hygienic Production and Transportation of Meat and Meat Products (AS 4696:2007).
But PrimeSafe treats all products that have gone through a cook process (to a minimum of 65C for a minimum of 10 minutes) as RTE. And you canâ€™t cryovac RTE products in Victoria without a Listeria Management Plan in place. Such a plan requires monthly listeria testing and quarterly testing of every product in its package exactly as it will be sold.
What does that mean in practice? Say we sell whole hams at Christmas, and sliced and half hams the rest of the year (in addition to sliced pastrami and other RTE products). We have to send off five whole packages per quarter of each product: five whole hams, five half hams, and five packages of sliced ham. The lab tests for listeria and then throws the meat away.
We only do whole hams at Christmas, and we only do about 40 of them. But this requirement would mean I would have to send five of those to be tested and disposed of. Thatâ€™s 12.5% of our hams thrown away. Or about $1000 in product, just for the whole hams. So to vac pack our RTE products would, weâ€™ve estimated, cost us around $5000 per annum in testing and sacrificed product.
Cost aside, we cannot stomach the idea of all that wasted food, especially from animals weâ€™ve raised so mindfully and whose lives weâ€™ve taken for the sole purpose of food. What total disrespect to simply throw that meat away. And so weâ€™ve opted not to pursue vac packing our RTE products. It means we have to run a tighter production model (we glad wrap our hams and hocks), but if thatâ€™s what it takes to respect the lives we take then itâ€™s what we will continue to do.
PrimeSafe considers smoked hocks to be RTE products, meaning we canâ€™t vac pack them. Bacon, interestingly, has an exemption from the RTE rule â€“ you are allowed to vac pack bacon because, as both The Auditor and The Inspector have told me, â€˜culturally, Australians cook baconâ€™. Smoked hocks donâ€™t have this exemption for reasons beyond me, in spite of the clear cultural evidence that Australians cook smoked hocks (ham & pea soup, anyone?).
And so when The Auditor asked why Iâ€™d vac packed my hocks, it was because she was about to slap me with a â€˜criticalâ€™, my first.
Following procedure when a â€˜criticalâ€™ is identified during an audit, The Auditor rang PrimeSafe. She spoke with The Inspector, and then handed the phone to me. The Inspector explained that The Auditor was going to have to condemn my smoked hocks â€“ that is, make me pull them out of their plastic, put them into a bin, and pour poison over them. DÃ©jÃ vu?
I asked whether we could have them tested?
I asked whether I could take them into my house for us to use?
I asked whether I could feed them to our dogs?
And so, weeping quietly, I pulled around 15 smoked hocks out of the fridge, cut the plastic off them, and put them into the same bin our salamis were poisoned in just a couple months earlier. The Auditor asked me to get the disinfectant I clean the floor with and poured it over the top of the hocks.
She then explained to me that PrimeSafe would put us on an Intensified Audit Schedule. Typically after a â€˜criticalâ€™ a shop will go on intensified audits for a minimum of four audits. That means an audit per week for a minimum of four weeks, at our expense (our audits average $350-$550 per audit).
Apparently the perverse incentive of this cost-recovery model to find a critical is lost on PrimeSafe and indeed the Victorian government?
Some clear questions remain:
- Who decides what is and isnâ€™t treated as a RTE product?
- Is there really a need to put a shop on intensified audits for a mistake such as mine? The rest of the audit found absolutely nothing wrong.
- Is there a cheaper and less onerous way to control the risk of listeria in RTE products? (eg you could pasteurize product in the vac pack to eliminate the risk without expensive, wasteful testing)
But now itâ€™s time to share another voice from Victoriaâ€™s beleaguered meat industryâ€¦
Felix Gamze of Gamze Smokehouse in Wangaratta has been a great mentor and friend to us as weâ€™ve navigated Victoriaâ€™s difficult regulatory terrain. Heâ€™s been a butcher for nearly 30 years, and has had his own negative experiences with PrimeSafe. Felix shared the story below with me for The Regulation Diaries as heâ€™s as committed as we are to seeking changes in the current situation to make it better for Victoriaâ€™s meat industry to do what we do.
In 2008 the Listeria guidelines came into place, effectively introducing guidelines and restrictions that forced 90% of butchers to stop making ham, bacon and smallgoods in their retail butcher shops in Victoria (something they had been doing for ever). I was one of the very few to persist with making my own smallgoods due to the passion I have for charcuterie.
Having been making smallgoods from my retail butcher shop for over 25 years I was determined to keep going due to the encouragement of my loyal customers. I thought, â€˜well it canâ€™t be too hard to comply with the guidelines as I have been safely making product for a long time and have never had a food safety issue.â€™
Not long after the new guidelines came into place our industry body put on an information evening in the local area and all the butchers from the region who were interested in continuing to make smallgoods attended. Now letâ€™s be honest, the room consisted of middle-aged butchers whose formal academic education averaged about form 4. This group of people were trained and very experienced in butchery, smallgoods making, food safety and running a small business.
The information session took about 2 hours and at the end we were all expected to fully understand and implement the new guidelines in our businesses! This was not the case and many of us left not fully understanding our new responsibilities. The new guidelines just put another job on the ever-growing requirements of a small business owner. The larger manufacturers didnâ€™t have the same concern as they would now just employ another staff member to cover the area full time.
A lot of the guidelines focused on food safety, something we were all very aware of and complied with for many years without a formal set of guidelines. But another large part was the introduction was copious amounts of paperwork, laboratory testing, and bureaucracy all of which were poorly explained, implemented and set out, not to mention very costly. It was clear that what Prime Safe was looking to do was to stop the small local butcher making and selling smallgoods, something that the big guys in the industry were obviously very happy about.
Soon after the information evening I had my first audit under the new guidelines and it wasnâ€™tÂ a very pleasant experience. At my first attempt I didnâ€™t correctly complete the paper work required and the auditor failed me. I had a visit from Prime Safe the next day. During the visit from Prime Safe they destroyed all my products buy pouring bleach on it and took my cooking licence off me for 2 years!
Now, this was not due to any food safety issues, it was purely a paperwork non-compliance issue. From that point I could have easily given up and stopped what I loved doing, but thatâ€™s what they wanted me and every other butcher in Victoria to do.
After two years of jumping through every hoop they put in front of me I managed to get my licence back and start making smallgoods again.
I was then asked to give evidence in the 2013 State Government Inquiry into the Impact of Food Safety Regulation on Farms and Other Businesses where I shared my experience with Prime Safe and offered suggestions on cutting red tape. Since this enquiry there has been no recommendations taken up by Prime Safe from the Inquiry and now 2 years later they are having another reviewâ€¦ I wonder what this will achieve.
Recently we decided to run Smallgoods and Butchery Masterclasses at our new facility where I would instruct a hands-on day of butchery and salami making. Once Prime Safe got wind of this they contacted me, instructing me that I was not allowed to conduct such a class. If I wanted to continue with the classes we would need to change it to making a fresh sausage and not a salami.
Each year I sell 100â€™s of kg of pork mince to local customers for them to make salami at home in June and July with some people having many years of experience and family heritage and others no idea at all. The families that have been making it for generations I have no worries about, but the average Joe that is interested in the art of charcuterie without access to a family with generations of experience I worry about. So I thought it would be a good idea to teach these people how to make salami safely and give them the knowledge to pass onto their family and start their own traditions. Obviously Prime Safe didnâ€™t see it that way.
We have run a number of these classes and the days have beenÂ a great success with butchery, smallgoods information and fresh sausage making taking place but unfortunately no salami.
Maybe one day we will be able to work with our regulator and not have them trying to trip us up. I will say one thing in addition to this and that is that I am always very concerned when speaking up with regards to past experiences with Prime Safe that my licence will be put in jeopardy.
Read Part 1 of The Regulation Diaries: PrimeSafe’s War on Salami Days
Read Part 2 of The Regulation Diaries: PrimeSafe’s War on Farm Gate Shops